Taddy & Co. - Prominent Footballers (1907) (2)

1907
Prominent Footballers
Taddy & Co.
595 cards (475 football, including 15 F.A. officials)

I have heard from Peter, a collector and football historian who has an interest in Taddy's Prominent Footballers cards.
Your list is a bit different to mine, so I would like to confront our sets. I like to treat FA officials and rugby players as subsets, so on my list there is 460 players names. 31 clubs x 15 players = 465 cards. For some reasons New Brompton and Wolves sets have 13 cards and Nottingham Forest 14. It makes 460.
I have added Peter's comments to each of the club subsets. There are a few players added that are missing from the original list. You can find the original list here: Taddy & Co. - Prominent Footballers (1907)

Aston Villa
15 players
My list is identical to yours.

J. Bache  -  Grapnel
C.L. Buckley  -  Grapnel
J. Cantrell  -  Imperial
R. Codling  -  Grapnel
W. Garratty  -  Grapnel
W. George  -  Imperial
L. Greenhalgh  -  Imperial
A. Hall  -  Imperial
H. Hampton  -  Grapnel
A. Leake  -  Imperial
J. Logan  -  Imperial
F. Miles  -  Imperial
C. Millington  -  Grapnel
H. Spencer  -  Grapnel
J. Walters  -  Imperial

Blackburn Rovers
15 players
Blackburn set is totally from team photo of 1907-08. I’ve never seen those four cards (****) but, I can imagine how they looks having the team picture.

E. Bracegirdle  -  Imperial
W. Bradshaw  -  Imperial
J. Cameron  -  Imperial
A. Cowell  -  Grapnel
R. Crompton  -  Grapnel   ****
W. Davies  -  Grapnel   ****
R. Evans  -  Grapnel
Griffiths  -  Grapnel
A.E. Houlker  -  Imperial
E. Latherton  -  Imperial
J. Martin  -  Grapnel
W. McIver  -  Imperial   ****
J. Robertson  -  Grapnel   ****
A. Whittaker  -  Imperial
S. Wolstenholme  -  Grapnel

Bolton Wanderers
15 players
There is some mystery with this set. I found two different portraits of Wattie White. There is no Bolton Wanderers set in 1908 (with footnote), so it has to be another version of 1907 set. (Update: the second illustration is false - there is only one Wattie White card). I have not seen the John Boyd card.

J. Baverstock  -  Grapnel
J. Boyd  -  Imperial   ****
R. Clifford  -  Imperial
D. Davies  -  Grapnel
J. Edmonson  -  Imperial
A. Gaskell  -  Imperial
S. Greenhalgh  -  Grapnel
S. Marsh  -  Grapnel
J. McEwan  -  Grapnel
A. Owen  -  Grapnel
A. Sheppard  -  Imperial
J. Slater  -  Imperial
J. Stanley  -  Grapnel
D. Stokes  -  Imperial
W. White  -  Grapnel

Bradford City
15 players
Just the same.

A. Bartlett  -  Grapnel
C. Campbell  -  Grapnel
W. Clarke  -  Grapnel
S. Farren  -  Grapnel
G. Handley  -  Imperial
H. Hanger  -  Imperial
S. Higginson  -  Imperial
J. McDonald  -  Imperial
J. McLean  -  Grapnel
J. Millar  -  Grapnel
W. Muir  -  Imperial
T. O'Rourke  -  Imperial
G. Robinson  -  Imperial
W. Smith  -  Grapnel
A. Wise  -  Imperial

Brighton & Hove Albion
15 players
I didn't have Hugh McDonald.

W. Anthony  -  Grapnel
A. Archer  -  Grapnel
R. Beale  -  Grapnel
J. Gregory  -  Imperial
J.H. Hall  -  Grapnel
A. Hulme  -  Imperial
R. Joynes  -  Imperial
H. Kent  -  Imperial
A.E. Longstaff  -  Grapnel
J. Lumley  -  Imperial
H. MacDonald  -  Grapnel
W. McDonald  -  Imperial
D. Ronaldson  -  Imperial
T. Turner  -  Imperial
R. Wombwell  -  Grapnel

Bristol City   -   updated
15 players

I think you’ve missed this club. I don't have the Fred Connelly card.

A. Annan - Imperial
H. Clay - Imperial
F. Connelly - Grapnel
L. Copestake - Grapnel
J. Cottle - Imperial
W. Demmery - Grapnel
S. Gilligan - Grapnel
P. Hanlin - Grapnel
F. Hilton - Grapnel
R. Marr - Grapnel
W. Maxwell - Imperial
A. Spear - Imperial
F. Stanifroth - Grapnel
W. Wedlock - Imperial
R. Young - Imperial

Cardiff (Rugby)
15 players

Chelsea
15 players
OK.

E.L. Birnie  -  Imperial
W. Bridgeman  -  Grapnel
W. Bridgeman  -  Imperial
N. Fairgray  -  Imperial
J.L. Frost  -  Grapnel
G. Henderson  -  Grapnel
G. Henderson  -  Imperial
G. Hilsdon  -  Grapnel
G. Hilsdon  -  Imperial
G. Key  -  Grapnel
G. Key  -  Imperial
J. Kirwan  -  Grapnel
J. Kirwan  -  Imperial
F. Lyons  -  Grapnel
F. Lyons  -  Imperial
R. Mackie  -  Imperial
R. McRoberts  -  Grapnel
M. Moran  -  Imperial
M. Moran  -  Grapnel
J. Stark  -  Grapnel
J. Stark  -  Imperial
R. Whiting  -  Grapnel
J.E. Windridge  -  Grapnel
J.E. Windridge  -  Imperial

Devonport Albion (Rugby)
15 players

Durham City  (Rugby)
15 players

Everton
15 players
OK.

W. Abbott  -  Imperial
R. Balmer  -  Imperial
W. Balmer  -  Imperial
H. Bolton  -  Grapnel
J. Crelley  -  Grapnel
H.P. Hardman  -  Imperial
H. Makepeace  -  Imperial
J. McConnachie  -  Grapnel
F.W. Rouse  -  Grapnel
W. Scott  -  Grapnel
J. Settle  -  Imperial
J. Sharp  -  Imperial
J.D. Taylor  -  Grapnel
A. Winterhalder  -  Imperial
A. Young  -  Grapnel

Fulham
15 players
OK.

F. Bevan  -  Imperial
A. Collins  -  Grapnel
R. Dalrymple  -  Imperial
A. Fraser  -  Grapnel
J. Fryer  -  Grapnel
W. Goldie  -  Imperial
J. Hogan  -  Imperial
A. Hubbard  -  Grapnel
T. Leigh  -  Imperial
A. Lindsay  -  Imperial
W. Morrison  -  Grapnel
H. Ross  -  Grapnel
L. Skene  -  Imperial
T. Threlfall  -  Grapnel
A. Wilkes  -  Imperial

Hull City
15 players
I missed the Tot Hedley and Martin Spendiff cards.

G. Browell  -  Grapnel
D. Gordon  -  Grapnel
E. Hall  -  Imperial
G.T. Hedley  -  Imperial
J. McQuillan  -  Imperial
E. Neave  -  Imperial
W.S. Robinson  -  Grapnel
E. Roughley  -  Imperial
Joe Shaw  -  Grapnel
John Shaw  -  Imperial
H. Simmon  -  Grapnel
Jack Smith  -  Imperial
Joe Smith  -  Grapnel
M. Spendiff  -  Grapnel
A. Temple  -  Grapnel

Ireland (Rugby)
15 players

Leeds City
15 players
OK.

J. Alfred  -  Grapnel
H. Bromage  -  Grapnel
J. Freeborough  -  Imperial
J.F. Hargreaves  -  Imperial
J. Henderson  -  Imperial
T. Hynds  -  Grapnel
R.W. Jefferson  -  Imperial
H. Kay  -  Imperial
J. Kennedy  -  Grapnel
J. Lavery  -  Grapnel
McLeod  -  Imperial
D.B. Murray  -  Grapnel
G.F. Parnell  -  Imperial
J. Thorp  -  Imperial
J. Whitley  -  Grapnel

Liverpool
15 players
OK.

J. Bradley  -  Grapnel
J. Cox  -  Grapnel
W. Dunlop  -  Imperial
J. Gorman  -  Grapnel
S. Hardy  -  Grapnel
J. Hewitt  -  Imperial
J. Hughes  -  Imperial
G. Latham  -  Imperial
J. Parkinson  -  Grapnel
M. Parry  -  Imperial
A. Raisbeck  -  Grapnel
R. Robinson  -  Imperial
P. Saul  -  Imperial
A. West  -  Imperial
C. Wilson  -  Grapnel

Manchester United
15 players
OK.

J. Bannister  -  Grapnel
A. Bell  -  Grapnel
W. Berry  -  Grapnel
H. Burgess  -  Imperial
R. Duckworth  -  Grapnel
R. Holden  -  Imperial
A. Menzies  -  Imperial
W. Meredith  -  Grapnel
H. Moger  -  Imperial
J. Picken  -  Grapnel
C. Roberts  -  Grapnel
A. Turnbull  -  Imperial
J. Turnbull  -  Imperial
G. Wall  -  Imperial
H. Williams  -  Grapnel

Middlesbrough
15 players
OK.

A. Aitken  -  Imperial
S. Aitken  -  Grapnel
W. Barker  -  Imperial
S. Bloomer  -  Grapnel
W. Brawn  -  Imperial
R. Brown  -  Grapnel
A. Campbell  -  Grapnel
A. Common  -  Imperial
J. Thackeray  -  Imperial
J. Tomlin  -  Grapnel
J. Tyldsley  -  Imperial
J. Watson  -  Imperial
F. Wilcox  -  Grapnel
T. Williamson  -  Imperial
T. Wilson  -  Grapnel

New Brompton
13 players
I’ve never seen the H.J. Slater card. In my list there is a place for H. Powell. Maybe it’s from 1908 set.

W.B. Floyd  -  Grapnel
D. Fullerton  -  Grapnel
J. Hartley  -  Imperial
E.A. Harvey  -  Imperial
J. Hopkins  -  Grapnel
G.H. Lloyd  -  Grapnel
W. Marriott  -  Grapnel
J. Martin  -  Grapnel
F. Mavin  -  Imperial
J. Pickering  -  Grapnel
H. Rowbotham  -  Imperial
H.J. Salter  -  Imperial   -   amended (typo)   -   Thanks to Matthew Zubrot
S. Smith  -  Imperial

Newcastle United
15 players
OK.

W. Appleyard  -  Imperial
J. Carr  -  Grapnel
A. Gardner  -  Imperial
A. Gosnell  -  Grapnel
J. Howie  -  Grapnel
J. Lawrence  -  Imperial
J. McClarence  -  Imperial
A. McCombie  -  Grapnel
W. McCracken  -  Grapnel
P. McWilliam  -  Grapnel
R. Orr  -  Imperial
J. Rutherford  -  Grapnel
J. Soye  -  Grapnel
F. Speedie  -  Imperial
C. Veitch  -  Imperial

Newport (Rugby)
15 players

New Zealand (Rugby)
15 players

Norwich City
15 players
I have no George Lamberton card.

T. Allsopp  -  Grapnel
W. Bushell  -  Imperial
H. Hutchison  -  Grapnel
A. Jones  -  Grapnel
G. Lamberton  -  Imperial
A. Livingstone  -  Imperial
J. McEwan  -  Grapnel
R. Muir  -  Imperial
G. Newlands  -  Imperial
W. Rayner  -  Imperial
P. Roney  -  Grapnel
W. Smith  -  Imperial
F. Thompson  -  Imperial
E. Wagstaffe  -  Grapnel
R. Whiteman  -  Grapnel

Notts Forest
14 players
I don't have the Bill Hooper card.

J. Armstrong  -  Imperial
W. Dudley  -  Imperial
Gibson  -  Imperial
A.W. Green  -  Imperial
W. Hooper  -  Imperial
E. Hughes  -  Grapnel
J.H. Linacre  -  Grapnel
G.H. Maltby  -  Grapnel
T. Marrison  -  Grapnel
A.G. Morris  -  Imperial
G. Needham  -  Grapnel
H.J. West  -  Imperial
H. Whitchurch  -  Grapnel
G. Wolfe  -  Grapnel

Portsmouth
15 players
OK.

M.W. Allman  -  Imperial
J. Bellamy  -  Grapnel
T. Birtles  -  Grapnel
T. Bowman  -  Grapnel
A. Buick  -  Imperial
F. Clipstone  -  Grapnel
W. Cooper  -  Grapnel
H. Digweed  -  Imperial
W. Kirby  -  Imperial
E. McDonald  -  Grapnel
G. Philip  -  Imperial
W. Smith  -  Imperial
H. Thompson  -  Grapnel
R. Walker  -  Grapnel
D. Wilson  -  Imperial

Preston North End
15 players
Looks OK. Although I missed three - George Barlow, Jack Bell and Arthur Lockett.

G.H. Barlow  -  Imperial
J. Bell  -  Grapnel
R. Bond  -  Grapnel
J. Carlin  -  Grapnel
J. Derbyshire  -  Grapnel
J. Hunter  -  Imperial
A. Lockett  -  Imperial
W.J. Lyon  -  Imperial
P. McBride  -  Grapnel
P. McBride  -  Imperial
J. McLean  -  Grapnel
T. Rodway  -  Imperial
W. Sanderson  -  Grapnel
P.J. Smith  -  Grapnel
H. Stringfellow  -  Imperial
H. Stringfellow  -  Grapnel
J. Wilson  -  Imperial

Queens Park Rangers
15 players
You missed the Arthur Walker card.

W. Barnes  -  Grapnel
S. Downing  -  Imperial
S. Downing  -  Grapnel
J. Fidler  -  Grapnel
A. Gittins  -  Imperial
A. Gittins  -  Grapnel
E. Hitchcock  -  Imperial
E.H. Linott  -  Imperial
J. MacDonald  -  Grapnel
J. MacDonald  -  Imperial
J. McLean  -  Grapnel
A. Mitchell  -  Imperial
A. Rogers  -  Imperial
C. Shaw  -  Grapnel
C. Shaw  -  Imperial
S.H. Sugden  -  Grapnel
A. Walker - Imperial    -   updated
J. White  -  Grapnel
W. Yenson  -  Grapnel
W. Yenson  -  Imperial

Reading
15 players
OK.

F. Bartholomew  -  Imperial
J. Boden  -  Grapnel
E. Coquet  -  Imperial
D. Dougal  -  Grapnel
F. Edgeley  -  Grapnel
E. Gee  -  Imperial
A. Hallworth  -  Imperial
J. Mack  -  Imperial
C. Mainds  -  Grapnel
C. McGhie  -  Grapnel
W. Minter  -  Grapnel
T. Pennington  -  Imperial
T. Rodger  -  Imperial
H. Smith  -  Imperial
W. Walker  -  Grapnel

Richmond R.F.C.
15 players

Sheffield United
15 players
I have no Alonzo Drake card. Charles and Harry Johnson are different players, like the Wilkinsons.

R. Benson  -  Grapnel
E.W. Bluff  -  Grapnel
W. Bromage  -  Grapnel
Brown  -  Imperial
A. Drake  -  Grapnel
Johnson - with moustache  -  Grapnel
Johnson - without moustache  -  Imperial
J. Lang  -  Imperial
J. Leivesley  -  Grapnel
H.B. Lipsham  -  Grapnel
J. McGuire  -  Imperial
M. Mellors  -  Imperial
E. Needham  -  Imperial
B. Wilkinson  -  Imperial
W. Wilkinson  -  Grapnel

Southampton
15 players
OK.

J. Bainbridge  -  Grapnel
E. Bell  -  Imperial
T. Burrows  -  Imperial
G. Costello  -  Grapnel
H. Glover  -  Grapnel
H. Hardley  -  Grapnel
F. Harrison  -  Imperial
A. Hodgkinson  -  Imperial
F. Jeffries  -  Imperial
J. Johnson  -  Imperial
J. Lewis  -  Grapnel
F. Mouncher  -  Grapnel
J. Robertson  -  Grapnel
G. Smith  -  Imperial
F. Thorpe  -  Imperial

Sunderland
15 players
OK.

S. Allen  -  Grapnel
Bonthron  -  Imperial
A. Bridgett  -  Imperial
Brown  -  Imperial
T. Daykin  -  Imperial
W. Hogg  -  Grapnel
G. Holley  -  Grapnel
G. Jarvie  -  Grapnel
Low  -  Imperial
A. MacIntosh  -  Grapnel
J. McGhie  -  Imperial
S. Raybould  -  Grapnel
E. Rhodes  -  Imperial
T.S. Tait  -  Imperial
R. Ward  -  Grapnel

Swansea (Rugby)
15 players

Swindon Town
15 players
I don't have Frank Heppinstall.

D. Aitken  -  Imperial
C. Bannister  -  Imperial
P. Chambers  -  Imperial
F. Fenton  -  Imperial
H. Fleming  -  Grapnel
J. Gill  -  Grapnel
F. Heppinstall  -  Imperial
J. Johnston  -  Grapnel
J. Kidd  -  Grapnel
A.S. Ling  -  Grapnel
H. Lyon  -  Imperial
G. Rushton  -  Grapnel
W. Tout  -  Grapnel
J. Walker  -  Imperial
F. Warburton  -  Grapnel

Tottenham Hotspur
15 players
There is no John Watson card on your list. 

W. Bull  -  Grapnel
W. Bull  -  Imperial
J. Darnell  -  Grapnel
J. Darnell  -  Imperial
J.A. Gray  -  Grapnel
J.A. Gray  -  Imperial
E. Hughes  -  Grapnel
E. Hughes  -  Imperial
W.D. McNair  -  Grapnel
W.D. McNair  -  Imperial
T. Morris  -  Grapnel
T. Morris  -  Imperial
J.E. Pass  -  Grapnel
J.E. Pass  -  Imperial
J. Reid  -  Grapnel
J. Reid  -  Imperial
H. Stansfield  -  Grapnel
H. Stansfield  -  Imperial
A. Tait  -  Grapnel
A. Tait  -  Imperial
J. Walton  -  Grapnel
J. Walton  -  Imperial
J. Watson  -  Grapnel   -  updated
J. Watson  -  Imperia   -  updated
J.G. Whitbourn  -  Grapnel
J.G. Whitbourn  -  Imperial
A. Whyman  -  Grapnel
A. Whyman  -  Imperial
V.J. Woodward  -  Grapnel
V.J. Woodward  -  Imperial

West Bromwich Albion
15 players
OK.

R. Bourne  -  Imperial
F. Buck  -  Grapnel
T. Dilly  -  Imperial
J. Evenson  -  Grapnel
G. Garrett  -  Imperial
Hayward  -  Imperial
W.C. Jordan  -  Imperial
J. Manners  -  Grapnel
H. Pearson  -  Imperial
J. Pennington  -  Grapnel
E. Pheasant  -  Grapnel
A. Randle  -  Imperial
F. Shinton  -  Grapnel
J. Stringer  -  Grapnel
D. Walker  -  Imperial

West Ham United
15 players
OK.

T. Allison  -  Imperial
F. Blackburn  -  Grapnel
D. Clark  -  Grapnel
A. Featherstone  -  Grapnel
W. Grassam  -  Imperial
A. Harwood  -  Grapnel
L. Jarvis  -  Imperial
G. Kitchen  -  Grapnel
T. Lee  -  Grapnel
D. Lindsay  -  Imperial
F. Pierey  -  Imperial
H. Stapley  -  Grapnel
A. Taylor  -  Imperial
W. Wildman  -  Imperial
R. Young  -  Imperial

Wolverhampton Wanderers
13 players
OK.

A. Bishop  -  Imperial
Collins  -  Grapnel
G. Hedley  -  Imperial
K.R.G. Hunt  -  Grapnel
K.R.G. Hunt  -  Imperial
J. Jones  -  Imperial
J.H. Jones  -  Imperial
A. Lloyd  -  Grapnel
A. Lloyd  -  Imperial
T. Lunn  -  Grapnel
J. Pedley  -  Grapnel
W. Radford  -  Imperial
J. Shelton  -  Grapnel
J. Shelton  -  Imperial
S. Ward  -  Imperial
W. Wooldridge  -  Grapnel

Woolwich Arsenal
15 players
Also OK.

J. Ashcroft  -  Grapnel
J. Ashcroft  -  Imperial
J. Bigden  -  Grapnel
J. Bigden  -  Imperial
J. Coleman  -  Grapnel
J. Coleman  -  Imperial
A. Cross  -  Grapnel
A. Cross  -  Imperial
J. Dick  -  Grapnel
J. Dick  -  Imperial
A. Ducat  -  Grapnel
A. Ducat  -  Imperial
A. Freeman  -  Grapnel
A. Freeman  -  Imperial
A. Gray  -  Grapnel
A. Gray  -  Imperial
P. Kyle  -  Grapnel
P. Kyle  -  Imperial
H.G. Lee  -  Grapnel
H.G. Lee  -  Imperial
R. McEachrane  -  Grapnel
R. McEachrane  -  Imperial
J. Mordue  -  Grapnel
J. Mordue  -  Imperial
D. Neave - Grapnel
D. Neave - Imperial
P.R. Sands - Grapnel
P.R. Sands - Imperial
J. Sharp  -  Grapnel
J. Sharp  -  Imperial

F.A. officials
15 players

J.J. Bentley, Esq  -  Imperial
Robert Cook, Esq  -  Grapnel
C. Crump, Esq  -  Grapnel
Alfred Davis, Esq  -  Imperial
R.P. Gregson, Esq  -  Grapnel
Rev. J.T. Hales  -  Imperial
A.G. Hines, Esq  -  Imperial
C.J. Hughes, Esq  -  Imperial
Rt Hon. Lord Kinnaird  -  Grapnel
J. Lewis, Esq  -  Imperial
W. McGregor, Esq  -  Grapnel
W. Pickford, Esq  -  Grapnel
G. Wagstaffe Simmons, Esq  -  Grapnel
H. Walker, Esq  -  Grapnel
D.B. Woolfall, Esq  -  Grapnel